Time to Downsize

By Sue Robbins

According to a 2007 report from the Trust for America’s Health, the incidence of obesity rose in 31 states in 2006, and no state saw a decrease. Unfortunately, as Americans struggle with weight management issues, the food industry and restaurants continue to offer larger and larger portions. Even dishware is larger. Since 1960 the average surface area of a dinner plate has increased by 36 percent. And studies clearly indicate that the more food that is put in front of people, the more they eat.

So why have portions grown so large in the past few decades? One of the main reasons is that America is blessed with an abundant food supply, so food is relatively inexpensive. However, labor is not. It’s cheap to make a bigger muffin and charge more.

Why do larger portions cause us to overeat? Most of us remember our parents saying “clean your plate,” and larger portions suggest to us that a bigger serving is the appropriate amount to eat. It’s easy to eat more when more is offered. Think about it. Do you really feel much fuller if you have 4 oz. of roast beef versus 3 oz.? That extra ounce a day can cause a weight gain of approximately 8 pounds in one year.

As a dietitian, I work with clients to help them understand portion control. But research indicates that education alone will not work. That’s what Prof. Brian Wansink of Cornell University figured out. He brought together 65 highly motivated students and spent 90 minutes explaining that if they were presented with a one-gallon bowl of snack mix, they would eat more than if they were presented with two half-gallon bowls. Six weeks later these same students were invited to a Super Bowl party. Half the students were led to a room where a one-gallon bowl of snack mix was served, and the other half went to a room where two half-gallon bowls were served. Despite their lesson with Prof. Wansink, the group presented with the one-gallon bowl served themselves 53 percent more snack mix than the other group and ate most of what they took. After the event they were asked if the size of the bowl influenced the amount they ate. All but two said it had no effect. So despite being educated about portion size, these students still ate more when they were presented with a larger bowl.

What’s the lesson here? In order to change our behavior, we need to promote the habit of eating smaller portions.
Here are a few suggestions:

  • Use smaller plates and bowls.
  • When eating at a restaurant, split a meal, or ask for a doggie bag and put half your meal away before you start eating.
  • Buy individually packaged snacks or repackage large bags into smaller containers.

Taking an active role in shaping our eating environment can help us downsize our supersized appetites.

Comments

Comments are subject to review and will not be posted immediately. If you have an urgent medical question, please consult a health care professional. If you have a question for the staff of Diabetes Forecast, please send it to replyall@diabetes.org.

Eat More and Urge More

Its a wonder knowing how elastic and expandable our stomach is. one can stretch the stomach a little more by eating a little more. once thats achieved, one can stretch it a little more on the next meal, and so on.
the practice of chewing food slowly and enjoying it at the same time, definitely helps to reduce the amount needed to satisfy one's appetite. its the surge in glucose level that sends signal of satisfaction/ fullness, rather than the quantity of food ingested. 

I have pretty much trained

I have pretty much trained myself to only eat half of a meal most of the time when we go to a restaurant. If I treat myself to McDonalds it is a Happy Meal minus the toy as the portion is right. It does get interesting to cook at our house as my husband is Gluten Intolerant to go along with my diabetes. With the fact most gluten replacement things are high glycemic, I really have to practice portion control to prevent a spike. It is all worth it as my husband is a cancer survivor now heading toward three and a half years in remission. My diagnosis of diabetes came fairly shortly before his diagnosis of two types of cancer.

common sense

Just so no, we do not need legislation or calls for action to the restaurant industry to cut the sizes of food...if people want to gorge themselves go for it...

overeating is not the only

overeating is not the only culprit for obesity, not doing the same amount of physical activity would cause obesity in most cases...

can a diabetic eat honey?

can a diabetic eat honey?

cinnamon,chromium

I recently heard that chromium helps the body deal with blood glucose. Can it be taken in conjunction with cinnamon ?

I already know that cinnamon works,as I've been using it for years,and it has lowered blood glucose. My A1C has consistantly been 6.1,but I noticed that the last few days blood glucose has been elavated from 99 to 159 in the morning,and as high as 335 in the evening. I do not trust the medical community as it seems that their priority is to sell presciption meds for pharmecutical cos. I've also recieved email that says honey in small amounts is good,is that fact or fiction

Low Carb AND Low Protein?? What's Left?

I just found out I have some kidney disease and need to limit my protein intake to 80 grams a day. If I need to keep carbs low (as a Diabetic) and I have to restrict my protein, what CAN I eat (besides drinking water)? Any advice is greatly appreciated... Thanks in advance.

I guess you can eat fruit

I guess you can eat fruit and vegies.

That's one thing i hate about these diseases, it feels like a dietary prison with lots of dos and donts.

(if you are Christian) I really believe diabetes is more than a mere condition, its a "blood eating demon". They are many records of prayer healing people though!

Limited carbs and protein = vegetables

Eat more vegetables! They are low in carbohydrates, proteins and fats, while being rather high in nutrients and generally available locally. Learn to freeze or can these as they are "in season" only for short time periods. Eating vegetables may initially promote flatulence, but your digestive system may adapt to the vegetables if you learn to chew thoroughly. Eating the food separately from all the water you need to be consuming, without sweeteners, caffeine or carbonation, will add to your diet comfort.
For decades I have eaten more vegetables than many others. A sibling developed an autoimmune condition requiring low protein intake and now eats lots of vegetables too. It is not a popular stance to take, but raw and lightly cooked vegetables, alone and in combinations, do provide ample taste in great variety. These vegetables can be affordable providing you learn to prepare and eat whatever vegetables are "in season" locally. Just do it.

Protine & kidney issues

I am a diabetic that has gone basicly vegetarian. Some fish, & chicken occasionaly. I reversed my kedney situation in only 6 months. Ck. out Dr. McDoogel's book. It is very interesting and the protine in legumes is not as distructive to the kidney. I have no trouble eating plunty and staying full between meals.
Hope this helps
Cat in NC on the chrystal coast

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Advertisement