2011 Insulin Pumps

Insulin injections are a lifesaver, but they can be limiting. That’s why many people forgo multiple daily injections and use an insulin pump.
By Tracey Neithercott

 

Product Listings

Some goals of pump therapy are to allow people with diabetes to delay a meal without going low, sleep in without worry, and exercise at will—instead of on a rigid schedule. Insulin pumps are pager-sized devices that continually deliver insulin via an infusion set: flexible, plastic tubing that connects to an under-the-skin cannula (a short tube). Since the infusion set is worn for two to three days at a time, you’ll stick yourself with a needle much less often than if you do multiple daily injections.

There are two ways in which a pump keeps blood glucose levels stable. First, it delivers a continuous dose of rapid-acting insulin all day long. This is known as your “basal rate,” and it’s how your glucose levels will stay steady overnight or between meals. Second, when you’re about to eat or if your blood glucose is too high, you can deliver a short burst of insulin—called a “bolus”—with the press of a button. If you’re fuzzy on the math, your pump’s bolus calculator will compute a suggested bolus based on your current blood glucose level, the amount of insulin in your system, and how many grams of carbohydrates you plan to eat. Each pump on the market gives you the option of delivering your bolus all at once, over an hour or two, or in a combination.

No two pumps are alike (click here for product listings), so it’s important to learn what elements suit the way you live.

Using an insulin pump can make diabetes management easier, but the ease comes with practice. All newbie pumpers should take a training course with a diabetes educator to learn how to wear the pump and to perform basic functions. It may be overwhelming at first, but with time you’ll learn to tweak treatment to suit your diabetes and lifestyle goals.

Before purchasing a pump, however, there are four main points that you should ponder:

1. Does the pump easily deliver your insulin dosage?
All pumps deliver about the same amount of insulin, but if you are very insulin sensitive or are choosing a device for a child who requires tiny doses, consider the pump’s basal and bolus ranges. Some can deliver as little as 0.025 units of insulin at a time. Those who require a lot of insulin may want to pick a pump with a larger reservoir size (they hold from 176 to 315
units of insulin).


2. If the pump is for a child, does it have kid-friendly features?
Regardless of the pump you pick, you’ll have a key lock option so your child (or you) won’t accidentally deliver a bolus at the wrong time. Some pumps are programmable from a remote, which may make it easier to change settings or administer insulin to children who won’t sit still. If disconnecting from the pump before bathing is a hassle for your child or you, look for one that’s waterproof.

3. Can you use the pump’s data management software on your computer?
Reviewing blood glucose and insulin data is an important part of your treatment, so pay attention to a pump’s data management tools. Pumps don’t just store data in their memory; all pumps but one offer software for downloading information, tracking trends, and creating graphs and tables that you can review with your doctor. It’s essential to note whether a pump’s software is compatible with your computer’s operating system. Some don’t work on Macs or with Windows 7.


4. Can you get an upgrade?
If you’re a veteran pumper using an old model, don’t assume your insurance company will fund an upgrade. You can ask for one, but you may have to hold out until your four-year pump warranty is up and you become eligible. (Always check with your insurer to be sure.) Certain companies offer upgrades for people wanting to try a newer model or switch to a different brand,
so ask customer service if you’re eligible.

Photo: Gary Landsman

Comments

Comments are subject to review and will not be posted immediately. If you have an urgent medical question, please consult a health care professional. If you have a question for the staff of Diabetes Forecast, please send it to replyall@diabetes.org.

Infusions, pumps and Win 98

Minimed infusions have become a disaster for me for the last 18 months of my 6 year experience with the Paradigm 722 insulin pump. While the Minimed Customer service reps tell you to use tape, tagaderm and other 'helpers', such are NOT covered by most insurance carriers. MM only sent such out for me, at their cost, for a limited time. The many steps needed for the MM cont. blood sugar sensor to successfully work and Heck, even stay on you, remind me of the Windows 98 fiasco. All THEIR talk, ALL Customer Cost and Do, no tangible results..... *Why make the transmitter waterproof if the part going into the bod isn't? Why bother if the whole thing falls off when wet? $35. dollars each, retail and they FALL OFF?? *A customer should not assume that doing 2 differing CGSs across a few weeks will both be completely and successfully saved in the MM pump. *Do not ever plan on putting even a pair of sweats between the pump and the sensor. Like rebooting Wins, 24 help line will have you, 'Finding Lost Sensor', 'Restart Old Sensor', etc. Animas infusions have been so much easier to use and dispose of. Dealing with the steps and limitations of CGS has me looking elsewhere and hoping to find the 'Apple' of insulin Pumps.

Question on pumps and how they work

From what I have gathered here the pump still has to have someone push a button to administer the insulin. Are there any pumps that can do this for the patient? A friend of mines elderly mother has trouble remembering when to take her meds or if she took them at all. We are looking for something that will eliminiate the risk of under or over medicating. Are there alarms that tell the patient to medicate or not to? What is the best suggestion for this type of patient? She currently does not qualify for in home care due to an income situation. She has to wait for three more years before she can qualify.

Re: Question on pumps...

Insulin pumps are a wonderful technology but they aren't for everyone. Those with limited hearing or eyesight should not use a pump. The elderly have thinner skin which would make current CGM technology quite painful to install. A family member who is familiar with diabetes care would be the answer for her. I wish the news were better.

Minimed Customer Service Unsatisfactory

I purchased my Minimed Pump and CGM system before any insurance companies even covered the CGMs. I loved the convenience of having the CGM reader in the pump itself. I did have numerous problems described above with the adhesion process, and I paid a lot out of pocket to replace early burnout. Nevertheless, i always assumed all would be like that, so the info above is great.

Alternatively, I order supplies about quarterly from Minimed Medtronic. In almost five years, they have NEVER gotten a suply order correct. They force us to comply with a littany of insurance and credit card requirements, and yet they are unable to correctly bill a primary, secondary, and a credit card. I havet tried the Web ordering, phone ordering, and even the mail-in card. Each time I have either:
1) had the order delayed due to misinformation or incorrect data on their end
2) when given instructions to all or email to inform me of problems on their end, they don't and I only find out because I have waited too long and called in.
3) they updated their system to report status online in the process..it has yet to be correct
4) they have forgotten to bill my credit card, which they have. when i reorder, they hold the order due to non-payment. they keep such bad hours, that customer service doesn't respond for days

In the end, i am always left to skimp on supplies, risk infectiom, and have creditors calling me.

Their sales reps have been great about calling me to upgrade now that I am out of warranty. very thorough followup there. they need to know that their customer service issues wil have me buying a new pump and CGM system.

Which pump do other consumers like?

I would like to know what kinds of pumps do other people with diabetes like the most and why?

omnipod

I have had great luck with the Omnipod system for 10 months now. Stays on for three days, no problem, even with swimming and heavy exercise. A little tape once in a while if it starts to come off. Much better than shots and tubing systems, in my opinion. Much better overall contol and comfort too. I use mine with the Dexcom CGM for peace of mind. There is a little learning curve with the pod but it is well worth it. Dave

Omni Pod

Dave,

I'm in the process of selecting an insulin pump. I'm really interested in the Omni Pod because of the convienience factor. My endochrinologist educator is saying that she gets more complaints about the omni pod then any other pump. She is trying to sell me on the medtronics and one touch. I don't like the tubing and priming and all the steps associated with it. Seems more simple to take shots. My gut feeling keeps bringing me back to the omnipod, but I would hate it if she came back to me and said, "I told you so!". What is the worst thing you are experiencing with the OmniPod?

OmniPod Feedback

Hi,

I have been using the OmniPod for years - and I couldn't love it more! Interestingly enough my educator also told me that people complained about it, but I just cannot understand why. The Pod is so comfortable I normally have to feel around to remember where I placed it. It is as discreet as I want it to be and they are actually working on a pod that's about 1/2 the size. I would never want the hassle of running tubing, and I have a very low basal dose so the siphoning effect of tubing would be a real problem for me.

If I had to rack my brain for problems;

1. Sometimes when I have it on my arm I forget it's there and if I'm hurrying and brush through a doorway, it will sometimes get caught and that can hurt.
2. I also use the Dexcom CGM - which unfortunately is only approved for stomach sites. If I put a pod over a dexcom site that's a little fresh I find it to be very itchy. I suspect I haven't finished healing from the CGM, but perhaps it's residual glue or something - not sure, so I don't do that.

3. The only other thing - The OmniPod is made by Insulet. Insulet has a contract with Abbott and includes the "Freestyle Flash" glucose meter built into the Omnipod PDM (remote). Recently Abbott changed the style of the test strips (butterfly strips) that are used in these meters (less sensitive to some medications). These new strips are not yet FDA approved in the OmniPod and Abbott doesn't care and stopped making the old strips.

You can ONLY get the old strips from select companies that simply still have old stock. If that is an issue for you, Abbott will send you a free meter to use with the new style strips - but it means you need to carry a meter as well which is just "One more thing"

THAT being said, what is before the FDA (I have been told by both Abbott and Insulet) is the same strips in the same Omnipod, "as is" with no other changes. The original Freestyle meters work with these new strips, so it stands to reason that it SHOULD all work - just be aware that it is not currently FDA approved.

Patiently waiting the mini-pod and FDA approvals for the new strips. I can't imagine any other anything being easier to use. I did MDI for over 20yrs before switching to the POD - and I would say that my only regret is that I didn't switch sooner. Complaints about DexCom are long ... :) But we won't go there.

Best of luck!

Pump Experience with Medtronic

I have pumped for 15 years. I have always used Medtronic Minimed. The adhesives in the past 5yrs have worked well for me even in water and submersion. I have not had too many bad experiences with Customer Service even when trying to work around upgrading my pump. If the current infusion set you use does not work, try another one! I have to use the QuickSet. The Silhouette is too painful for me but when I have to use it I do. I cannot use the butterfly infusion set. I also do not need extra adhesives now. From my experience most if not all insurance companies cover Medtronic Products. As for the coverage on the tapings, if they are included in the prescription write up the insurance will cover it (that is the only work around). However if not use your flex benefits or HSA and call it a day. Otherwise claim it on your taxes.

reply

Are you Medtronic emploeyee?? . It seems so. Your post is just addvertisment. It is shame on you/ And I hat MEDTRONIC

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Advertisement